top of page
Search

The Elysium Stone, Four Pounds of Lander Blue from Landscape to Treasure.

1 day ago
12 min read

Neil Ray, West Texas Analytical Laboratory, Geochemist & Mineralogist.




Summary

            The Elysium stone is a four-pound piece of lower grade Lander Blue wall rock that Marvin Syme traded to Richard Dann, and which sat in Dann’s rock garden in Carlin, Nevada, for about 50 years.  XRF analysis of four zones shows zinc content and zinc to copper and iron to copper ratios that match reference Lander Blue, supporting the documented provenance.  Mobile elements, including chlorine, uranium, calcium, strontium, magnesium, and arsenic, are depleted relative to Lander Blue, a weathering signature, while the iron-rich crust retained uranium and the exposed surface accumulated manganese, cobalt, and nickel.  Cabochons cut from the vein display the spiderweb patterns typical of Lander Blue.


Mine History

            Turquoise from the Lander Blue claim is considered the most coveted and sought after turquoise in existence, with most material yielding gem grade spiderweb turquoise.  Lander Blue was always known as a hat mine, meaning the production from the claim was so small that it could fit in a hat and indeed recovery estimates place the total yield at around 100 pounds (Lowry and Lowry 2010; Ryan and Chambless 2020).  Although Lander Blue is known for its classic high-grade look, the claim also produced lower grade turquoise, and lower grade wall rock was certainly removed during mining operations.  The history of Lander Blue can be found in Turquoise in America Part Two 1910-1990, so it will only be briefly discussed in this article.  The mine was found in 1973 by Rita Hapgood, a Battle Mountain blackjack dealer, who later sold the claim to Marvin Syme and Henry Dorian, who brought in Bob Johnson to work the claim; the Lander Blue Turquoise Corporation was formed.  Marvin Syme was very particular with any rough he acquired and only notably traded turquoise with Jim Elquist and Richard Dann.  Jim Elquist was the owner and operator of the Blue Gem Mine and Richard Dann was the principal miner of the Indian Mountain Mine; their stories can also be found in Turquoise in America Part Two. 1910-1990 and Turquoise in America Part Three, The Stories of Turquoise, 1990-2020.


The Rock

Marvin Syme traded with Richard Dann a four-pound nugget of Lander Blue, which encompasses a vein of turquoise surrounded by what is mostly host rock, in exchange for Indian Mountain rough.  The four-pound rock represents undocumented lower grade wall rock that was removed during mining.  For reasons unknown Richard never worked the rock and placed it in his rock garden as permanent décor.  The rock incredibly sat undisturbed in his rock garden in Carlin, Nevada for roughly 50 years, until it was recently recovered and sent to West Texas Analytical Laboratory (WTAL) for examination.  The rock was nicknamed the Elysium stone; Elysium has its roots in Greek mythology, meaning a place where heroes and the righteous went to rest, later referring to a blissful garden and yet another meaning is to release.  Release is well fitted as element leaching due to weathering is observed in the specimen and consequently unique chemical alteration patterns are observed.  Turquoise is formed in arid environments and long-term exposure to weathering can cause elemental leaching of mobile elements and chemical alteration, which makes it problematic to match trace element chemistry to mine origin.  Nevertheless, analyses were carried out on multiple spots on the rock, and comparison with known Lander Blue strongly supports a Lander Blue origin and the account of Marvin Syme’s exchange with Richard Dann.




       

The Elysium stone, a four-pound nugget of Lander Blue, showing a rich turquoise vein encompassed by host rock.

 

Geochemistry and Mineralogy

            The rock contains three distinct phases: a dark gray crust, a black silicified shale with sporadic micro dots of turquoise, and a distinct turquoise vein.  The gray crust is predominately quartz with strengite and the black micro dot phase is quartz, turquoise, and strengite.  Strengite is a hydrous iron phosphate, related to turquoise but lacking the copper and aluminum.  It forms by oxidation of iron and recrystallization of phosphate, by hydrothermal alteration or even as a product of weathering (Banfield et al. 1999).  Partial dissolution of turquoise releases phosphate, leaving behind iron to reprecipitate as secondary strengite.  The strengite largely predates the rock garden, forming during near surface oxidation of the lower grade wall rock within the deposit; its concentration in the exterior gray crust was likely enhanced by later surface exposure.

           

 Wt. %

Gray Crust

Black Microweb

Exterior Vein

Interior Vein

SiO2

45.33

13.93

8.16

1.76

Al2O3

10.77

10.51

15.48

32.47

MgO

0.50

0.54

0.69

0.50

CaO

1.02

0.25

0.25

0.14

K2O

1.18

0.43

0.32

0.13

Na2O

0.70

0.32

0.11

0.12

P2O5

15.41

29.38

24.69

38.56

TiO2

0.19

0.14

0.06

0.01

MnO

0.07

0.03

0.02

0.02

FeO

3.91

1.21

0.25

0.11

Fe2O3

4.78

7.92

2.17

1.33

S

0.33

0.23

0.16

0.15

Cl

0.05

0.15

0.003

0.003

 

 

 

 

 

ppm wt.

Gray Crust

Black Microweb

Exterior Vein

Interior Vein

Strontium

3726

413

113

23

Barium

6201

1867

1748

1487

Rubidium

33

10

4

2

Zirconium

106

55

15

3

Molybdenum

76

112

120

119

Vanadium

388

270

141

143

Nickel

103

49

50

76

Copper

243

11726

61832

72221

Zinc

278

261

3036

3387

Chromium

325

177

162

219

Lead

12

9

6

5

Arsenic

72

121

149

180

Tungsten

45

38

69

122

Antimony

94

81

134

104

Tin

22

29

25

17

Silver

41

35

12

10

Bismuth

9

5

5

5

Niobium

18

7

2

2

Uranium

13

13

5

6

Thorium

6

4

3

3

Selenium

257

298

33

11

Cobalt

601

276

110

82

Cadmium

19

19

22

13

Bulk and trace element chemistry of the Elysium Lander Blue Rock

The chemical analyses are indicative of a Lander origin, most notably zinc, which at 3036 ppm on the surface and 3387 ppm in the interior, fall inside the range of Lander Blue of 1093-4868 ppm and close to the median of 2868 ppm.  In an earlier study of Lander Blue, zinc substitution was a noted fingerprint of Lander Blue origin (Ray 2024).  Zinc and iron substitution in turquoise is a key indicator for origin qualification, zinc to copper ratio is 0.049 and 0.047 respectively, against a Lander Blue median of 0.051.  Additionally, iron to copper, at 0.28 on the surface matches the median at 0.29.  The interior consists of purer turquoise and has a ratio of 0.14, still within the range of Lander Blue.  Major elements are broadly consistent with Lander Blue.  Copper and phosphorus in the exterior vein fall within the Lander Blue range, while the interior vein, being nearly pure turquoise, sits slightly above the range for both.  Aluminum in the exterior vein is slightly below the range, consistent with the aluminum leaching discussed below.  Because these concentrations depend on how much matrix is present, the zinc to copper and iron to copper ratios are the more reliable comparison.


Major element comparisons of the Elysium rock against Lander Blue reference specimens; gray boxes show the Lander Blue range and black lines the median for each element

            Mobile elements that are affected by weathering are chlorine, uranium, calcium, strontium, magnesium, and arsenic.   These unique elements provide a fingerprint into the weathering profile of the Elysium stone, as if the specimen came from a different source, these elements could be higher or lower with variability.  However, all of these elements are lower and indicate depletion, which is what a weathering pattern would produce.   The most interesting is the depletion of uranium, as it’s well noted from a previous study on Lander Blue that uranium is a distinctive geochemical marker for Lander Blue origin, however the vein contains only 6 ppm, which is notably eight times less than the median for Lander Blue.  In oxidizing near surface water, uranium is present as the uranyl ion, which forms stable complexes with carbonate, phosphate, and sulfate.  These complexes keep uranium dissolved across a pH range of 5 to 12 (Health Canada) and irrigation water has been shown to leach uranium from sediments (Tillman et al. 2021).  It is well noted that even small amounts of bicarbonate can rapidly leach uranium, including bound up uranium in phosphates such as turquoise (Zhou and Gu 2005).  In calcium rich water, uranium is released together with calcium, as calcium uranyl carbonate complexes, which bind only weakly to mineral surfaces (Skierszkan et al. 2021).  At a pH greater than 6.5, carbonate complexes dominate uranium chemistry in most water, thus depletion of uranium is explained by coinciding depletion of calcium, with uranium loss to a greater degree.  The gray crust and the black microweb portions contain more than double the amount of uranium, as iron oxyhydroxides are natural traps that trap and immobilize uranium from water exposure (Lahrouch et al. 2021), thus the iron rich matrix captured some of the released uranium from the turquoise vein.  Another apparent geochemical attribute to weathering is that the crust is enriched in manganese, cobalt, and nickel compared to the vein.  Manganese oxides form surface coatings on exposed rocks, which uptake heavy metals such as cobalt, nickel, and lead from regular water uptakes (Li et al. 2024; Grangeon et al. 2020), consistent with a rock that has sat in a rock garden for years.  Turquoise is porous and weathering would have occurred throughout the whole rock, and it was likely already weathered when it was found and sitting in a rock garden simply continued the process.  Sun exposure contributes physically rather than chemically: daily heating and cooling and repeated wetting and drying drive water through the porous rock and draw dissolved salts toward the surface, accelerating the loss of mobile elements such as chlorine.  The formation of strengite is a consequence of long term near surface weathering within the deposit, where immobile iron and phosphorus reacted to precipitate it, largely before the rock was mined.  Copper and aluminum leaching during the rock garden years may have continued this process at the exposed surface.

 

 

Lander Blue Range

Lander Blue Median

Exterior Vein

Interior Vein

Depletion vs Median

Chlorine

1643-7055 ppm

4001 ppm

35 ppm

31 ppm

120X

Uranium

27-77 ppm

45 ppm

5.3 ppm

5.8 ppm

8X

Strontium

35-2649 ppm

386 ppm

113 ppm

23 ppm

3-17X

Calcium

0.11-1.98%

0.53%

0.18%

0.10%

3-5X

Magnesium

0.85-1.28%

1.02%

0.42%

0.30%

2.4-3.4X

Arsenic

193-1661 ppm

530 ppm

149 ppm

180 ppm

3X

 

Depletion of mobile elements in the Elysium rock due to weathering

 

Mineralogy of the Lander Blue Claim

            Lander Blue is described as a hat mine because of its very small production, a consequence of turquoise deposition in a near surface pocket rather than the wide continuous veins typical of copper porphyry associated deposits.  The claim itself was small, reportedly about 600 by 600 feet rather than the typical 20-acre claim, and the high grade “honey hole” was said to be only about 20 feet across; lower grade turquoise undoubtedly came from a wider area of the claim. The host rock is a sheared iron-rich shale, where shearing was induced by the Antler Orogeny, a major mountain building collision that occurred 370 million years ago, during the late Devonian (Evans and Theodore 1978).  This event displaced deep ocean sedimentary rocks at least 90 km eastward over shallow water carbonate rocks along the Roberts Mountains Thrust.  Further compression from the Sevier and Laramide Orogenies, 140 and 55 million years ago, subjected the region to squeezing; reactivating fault zones and fracturing brittle sedimentary rock.  Turquoise formation postdates the onset of Basin and Range extension about 17 million years ago, when the crust began pulling apart, allowing fluids to circulate and deposit turquoise (National Park Service).  Lander Blue turquoise allowed for minimal iron substitution, which is the primary reason for its rich blue coloration, as most of the iron went into the host rock.  It is noted that higher concentrations of iron will cause the turquoise to develop a green coloration.  The leaching of copper and aluminum, leaving behind immobile iron from the matrix, coupled with available phosphorus produced strengite.  Though not the highest grade, strengite occurrence in the black microweb is a pinkish, violet, or red color and adds to the uniqueness of the material; strengite-bearing matrix of this kind likely represents the lower grade fringe of the deposit outside the honey hole.  The Elysium rock has yielded two characteristic turquoise cabochons from the turquoise vein (aside from matrix dotted material), the first of which shows a high hardness and a nice blue cloud like matrix and spiderwebbing.  The second is the more classic Lander Blue look with deep blue coloration and intricate gold spiderwebbing.  The spiderweb cabs would not make gem grade, but they are high grade and show incredible matrix patterns that Lander Blue is famous for.



 

Chert matrix cabs cut from the Elysium stone with minor turquoise and strengite.



Spiderweb cabs cut from the Elysium stone showing a cloud like matrix.


High grade spiderweb cabs cut from the Elysium stone showing the classic Lander Blue look.



            The gray crust of the Elysium rock consists of quartz and strengite with trace turquoise, as well as minor crandallite.  Crandallite is a calcium aluminum phosphate, its presence and localization to the gray surface crust is further indicative of weathering (Vieillard et al. 1979).  Crandallite forms as a direct alteration product of phosphates in the presence of calcium due to repeated water exposure, most likely during near surface weathering within the deposit before the rock was mined.  The gray crust also contains secondary epidote (zoisite) and chlorite that is a product of hydrothermal alteration of the host rock.  The black microweb contains turquoise and strengite within a chert matrix and the vein itself is nearly pure turquoise. Iron bearing minerals such as hematite are confined to the matrix and are higher in the gray crust.  The mineralogy is comparable to other specimens of Lander Blue, which shows a feldspar rich quartz matrix with accessory hematite.  A further study of the mineralogy of Lander Blue reference specimens can be found in an earlier posted article (Ray, 2024).

 

 

Gray Crust

Black Microweb

Exterior Vein

Interior Vein

Quartz

40.34

16.07

7.53

0.43

Orthoclase

6.25

2.95

2.04

0.69

Hematite

5.70

2.11

0.69

0.35

Turquoise

0.41

47.85

86.73

97.64

Crandallite

2.57

0.00

0.00

0.00

Ankerite

1.48

3.66

2.25

0.00

Siderite

0.00

1.72

0.00

0.00

Chlorite/Serpentine

1.27

0.00

0.00

0.00

Illite/Clays

10.64

0.00

0.48

0.00

Zoisite/Clinozoisite

3.11

0.00

0.00

0.00

Strengite

26.39

24.72

0.00

0.00

Accessory phases (<1%)

1.83

0.92

0.27

0.88

Mineralogy of the Elysium stone (wt. %), calculated using the P3M algorithm; phases below 1% in every zone are combined as accessory phases

 

Conclusion

            The Elysium stone represents an unusual specimen of Lander Blue from the undocumented mass of lower grade matrix wall rock that was removed during the mining operations of the Lander Blue Turquoise Corporation.  Additionally, it represents a unique piece of history with changing ownership from Marvin Syme to Richard Dann, as well as a unique look at the weathering effects of turquoise when exposed to the harsh conditions of a rural landscape.  The turquoise remained hard enough to withstand the long storage conditions of a rock garden.  Cabochons cut from the stone show the defining matrix patterns and coloration that is typical of Lander Blue.  Though not gem grade, most are high grade and the lower grade matrix cabs show a unique mineralogy of the oxidation and alteration of the Lander Blue deposit and the prolonged weathering pattern from years of exposure in a rock garden.  


Acknowledgments   

West Texas Analytical Laboratory is not affiliated with Turquoise in America and nor does it receive economic compensation for promotion from either and nor does either receive compensation for the promotion of the lab.  This collective collaboration is simply made possible for the love of turquoise.  I am a geochemist with over 15 years laboratory experience and graduate level research on metasomatic and hydrothermal emplacement.  If you are interested in submitting samples for analysis, you may contact West Texas Laboratory at 580-324-7148.  The cost is $65 for a comprehensive analysis that includes mineralogy, origin, grade, and more or $35 for a simple chemical analysis to identify if it is turquoise and natural or treated.


References

Banfield, J. F., Barker, W. W., Welch, S. A., and Taunton, A. (1999). Biological impact on mineral dissolution: application of the lichen model to understanding mineral weathering in the rhizosphere. PNAS, 96(7), 3404–3411. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC34281/

Evans, J. G., and Theodore, T. G. (1978). Deformation of the Roberts Mountains Allochthon in North-Central Nevada. U.S. Geological Survey Professional Paper 1060. https://pubs.usgs.gov/pp/1060/report.pdf

Grangeon, S., Bataillard, P., and Coussy, S. (2020). The nature of manganese oxides in soils and their role as scavengers of trace elements: implication for soil remediation. In Environmental Soil Remediation and Rehabilitation (pp. 399–429). Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-40348-5_7

Lahrouch, F., Guo, N., Hunault, M. O. J. Y., Solari, P. L., Descostes, M., and Gerard, M. (2021). Uranium retention on iron oxyhydroxides in post-mining environmental conditions. Chemosphere, 264, 128473. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.128473

Li, F., Yin, H., Zhu, T., and Zhuang, W. (2024). Understanding the role of manganese oxides in retaining harmful metals: insights into oxidation and adsorption mechanisms at microstructure level. Eco-Environment & Health, 3(1), 89–106. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eehl.2024.01.002

Lowry, J. D., and Lowry, J. P. (2010). Turquoise: The World Story of a Fascinating Gemstone. Layton, UT: Gibbs Smith. 256 pp. ISBN 9781423602897.

National Park Service, Parashant National Monument. Stretching of the Basin and Range and Lifting of the Colorado Plateau.  https://www.nps.gov/para/learn/nature/stretching-of-the-basin-and-range-and-lifting-of-the-colorado-plateau.htm

Ray, N. (2024). Guest Article: Identifying Lander Blue With XRF. Turquoise in America. https://www.turquoiseinamerica.com/post/guest-article-identifying-lander-blue-with-xrf

Ryan, M., II, and Chambless, P. (2020). Turquoise in America, Part Two: 1910–1990. Santa Fe, NM: Callais Press. https://www.turquoiseinamerica.com/

Skierszkan, E. K., Dockrey, J. W., Helsen, J., et al. (2021). Persistence of uranium in old and cold subpermafrost groundwater indicated by linking ²³⁴U–²³⁵U–²³⁸U, groundwater ages, and hydrogeochemistry. ACS Earth and Space Chemistry, 5(12), 3474–3487. https://doi.org/10.1021/acsearthspacechem.1c00307

Tillman, F. D., Beisner, K. R., Anderson, J. R., et al. (2021). An assessment of uranium in groundwater in the Grand Canyon region. Scientific Reports, 11, 22157. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-01621-8

Vieillard, P., Tardy, Y., and Nahon, D. (1979). Stability fields of clays and aluminum phosphates: parageneses in lateritic weathering of argillaceous phosphatic sediments. American Mineralogist, 64, 626–634. http://www.minsocam.org/ammin/am64/am64_626.pdf

Zhou, P., and Gu, B. (2005). Extraction of oxidized and reduced forms of uranium from contaminated soils: effects of carbonate concentration and pH. Environmental Science & Technology, 39(12), 4435–4440. https://doi.org/10.1021/es0483443

 

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page